Stay Forever

+112% Online Revenue Growth for Gift Shop Stay Forever Through Discovery Rebuil

Stay Forever Hero Section Image

What We Did

  • Shopify UX and UI Design
  • Conversion Rate Optimization (CRO)
  • Gift Guide and Discovery Architecture
  • Multi-Category Navigation Rebuild
  • In-Store to Online Experience Bridge

The Challenge

Stay Forever is a thousand things in one place. A curated gift shop. A baby and kids store. A collectibles destination for Jellycat, Sonny Angel, Smiski, and Miffy fans. A home goods corner. A kids classes venue. A Latina and AAPI-owned community space across three New York locations. The old site could not hold all of it. Shoppers came looking for a gift and got lost inside a catalog that had no point of view.

Stay Forever Website Home Page Design

Our Approach

Walking into Stay Forever feels like being handed a gift you did not know you wanted. Someone with taste has already done the hard work. The site needed to do the same. Not flatten everything into a grid, but guide people the way the staff does in store.

 

So we rebuilt the homepage around discovery, not departments. “Things you’ll love forever” became an actual entry point, with curated rails pulled from what is selling in Ridgewood and Catskill that week. The Gift Guide moved to the top of the navigation because gift shoppers are the highest-intent buyers, and we gave them real paths to walk down instead of a single grid: by age, by recipient, by vibe. Collectibles got their own merchandising logic since Sonny Angel and Jellycat fans shop differently than everyone else. And the three retail locations finally got proper storefront pages, so the physical shops and the online store feel like one business, not four.

From Gift Search to Checkout, Without the Overwhelm

Gift shoppers do not browse. They hunt. Our job was to get them to the right product fast and then give them reasons to add one more thing:

  • Gift Guide entry points for age, occasion, price, and recipient
  • Surprise Curated Gift Box placed prominently for shoppers
  • Free shipping progress bar with specific add-on suggestions
  • Collectible series grouped by character, not by product category
  • In-store pickup surfaced at checkout for Queens and Catskill locals
  • Kids classes moved into the main nav
Stay Forever Website Product View

The Results

  • +112% online revenue growth year over year following the relaunch
  • Average order value up 34% after the gift guide rebuild
  • Mobile conversion rate nearly doubled after the discovery rebuild
  • Gift card and gift box purchases grew by 61%
  • Class bookings moved meaningfully online, reducing phone and in-person booking load
  • Cross-category basket rate up sharply among returning customers

Final Word

From a curated shelf in Ridgewood to a cart full of things someone will genuinely love, we helped Stay Forever build an online shop that finally feels like walking through their door. Warm, weird, full of taste, and run by people who actually care.

Want results like Stay Forever?

Book a free call and we’ll review your store and show you where the biggest gains are, with a clear plan before any work starts. See how we approach Shopify CRO.

100% Satisfaction Guarantee

We stand behind our service with a 100% Satisfaction Guarantee. If you’re not completely satisfied with our service, we’ll make it right at no additional cost, or provide a full refund with no questions asked. Your success is our success.

Woman stretching in an office to show the flexibility Bulk Hours offer for handling ongoing tasks.